President Donald Trump scored a significant legal victory Thursday in his defamation lawsuit against The New York Times, with a federal judge in Florida refusing to dismiss four counts of his lawsuit and finding that allegations involving accusations of tax fraud and other criminal wrongdoing could proceed.
The ruling Thursday by U.S. District Judge Steven D. Merryday represents a major success for Trump’s legal team, which has argued that the newspaper and its journalists knowingly published false and damaging accusations about the president and his family’s business dealings.
In a 12-page order, Merryday denied the defendants’ motions to dismiss Counts I, II, V and VI of Trump’s amended complaint, while dismissing Counts III and IV.
Importantly, the judge ordered the defendants to answer the surviving claims within 28 days, advancing the litigation beyond a critical early hurdle.
At the center of the dispute are allegations published in the book Lucky Loser, written by New York Times journalists Russ Buettner and Susanne Craig, along with reporting concerning Trump’s finances and business history.
Trump challenges statements alleging that he received more than $400 million from his father through fraudulent tax schemes, benefited from sham transactions designed to evade estate and gift taxes, and profited from inflated invoices involving family properties.
Another challenged statement alleged that authorities investigated Trump’s Mafia connections, discovered money-laundering violations, and penalized him for stock-trading violations.
Merryday concluded that Trump’s complaint plausibly alleged the defendants published certain accusations of complex criminal conduct without obtaining the specialized legal and financial analysis necessary to substantiate them.
The judge sharply questioned whether journalists could confidently accuse someone of sophisticated tax crimes based on limited expert commentary.
He wrote that publishing such allegations without adequate expert verification could constitute "purposeful avoidance of the truth," a critical consideration under the Supreme Court’s landmark New York Times v. Sullivan standard.
https://www.newsmax.com/newsfront/trump-nytimes-defamation/2026/11/19/id/1276942/










